DraftKings Pick6 vs Underdog: DFS Comparison

DraftKings Pick6 and Underdog Fantasy are both popular fantasy sports platforms, but they offer distinct experiences for players. While both platforms allow for free and paid contests, DraftKings Pick6 is more focused on real-time predictions, whereas Underdog Fantasy provides options for both short-term and long-term fantasy play. Ultimately, DraftKings Pick6 appeals to those interested in player matchup predictions, while Underdog Fantasy caters to users who enjoy player props and drafting teams for the season.

I tried out both sites and found plenty to enjoy about each. I signed up as a new DraftKings Pick6 customer and received $50 in Pick6 Credits after entering a $5 contest as my first entry. Then I signed up for Underdog and was able to claim up to $1,000 in bonus cash on my first deposit.

Read on for my complete review of how DraftKings Pick6 compares to Underdog Fantasy, including details on each welcome offer, how each platform operates, and what to expect when making picks.

Claim Your Share of Millions in Prizes at DraftKings
Claim Your Share of Millions in Prizes at DraftKings
Your Share of Millions in Prizes
With $5 Deposit
  • Play Free for your Share of Millions with First Deposit
  • T&Cs Apply. Gambling Problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER
  • To Claim: Click Play Now

Welcome Bonus Comparison: DraftKings Pick6 vs. Underdog

DraftKings Pick6 offers a $50 bonus in site credits when you make your first deposit. This flat bonus is helpful because it requires a low minimum deposit of $5.

Meanwhile, Underdog Fantasy provides a 50% deposit match bonus of up to $1,000, which is ultimately a larger sum. However, you have to front more of your own money to be able to claim the bonus. For instance, to get the same $50 bonus that Pick6 offers, I had to deposit $100 of my own money. To claim the full $1,000 bonus, I would’ve had to deposit $2,000 of my own money.

DraftKings Pick6

  • Bonus Offer: DraftKings offers a $50 bonus in site credits when you make your first deposit of $5+.
  • Wagering Requirement: You typically need to deposit a certain amount (e.g., $5–$10) and meet specific wagering requirements before you can withdraw any bonus funds.

Underdog Fantasy

  • Bonus Offer: Underdog offers a 50% deposit match for new users, up to $1,000.
  • Wagering Requirement: To withdraw bonus funds, you generally need to play through the bonus amount by entering paid contests or achieving certain levels of play.

How DraftKings and Underdog Fantasy work

DraftKings Pick6 is more about matchup-based fantasy sports predictions, while Underdog offers both long-term fantasy leagues (Best Ball) and daily Pick’em games for predicting stats. Below, I’ll explain how each one works.

How DraftKings Pick6 Works

In DraftKings Pick6, you select 6 matchups from a variety of sports (such as NFL, NBA, MLB), and for each matchup, you predict whether a player will overperform or underperform a specific fantasy points threshold.

Each matchup has fantasy points attached to it. For instance, I earned points based on how well my selected players performed in real-life games. The more accurate my predictions, the more points I score.

These Pick6 contests can either be free-to-enter or paid entry. The goal is to score more points than other contestants by making accurate predictions for all six matchups. I was able to win a variety of cash prizes, DraftKings credits, and free entries to other contests. Here’s what other Pick6 players have won this week:

DraftKings Pick6 Wins

How Underdog Fantasy Works

Underdog offers season-long fantasy leagues (Best Ball) and daily fantasy contests (Pick’em). You can enter free contests and play for fun, or take part in paid contests and compete for cash prizes. Prizes vary depending on the type of contest, but I was able to win cash prizes and site credits.

Best Ball: You draft a fantasy team for the season, and Underdog automatically selects your best-performing players each week. Points are awarded based on real-life performance throughout the season, and you do not have to make weekly roster decisions.

Pick’em: Players predict the over/under of player statistics for a single game or multiple games. For example, you can pick whether a player will score over or under a certain number of fantasy points, yards, or other stats. You score based on whether your picks (over/under) are correct, with the option to create multi-pick parlays for higher payouts.

Snake Drafts: Underdog also offers smaller nightly snake drafts, which are fast-paced draft events that pay out at the end of each nightly event.

Are DraftKings Pick6 and Underdog legal in Texas?

DraftKings Pick6 and Underdog Fantasy are legal in Texas, but with some important distinctions.

DraftKings Pick6

Legal Status: DraftKings Pick6 operates legally in Texas because it offers fantasy sports contests, which are legal in the state. Texas law specifically permits fantasy sports betting, so DraftKings’ fantasy offerings (including Pick6) are allowed.

Underdog Fantasy

Legal Status: Underdog Fantasy also operates legally in Texas because it is a fantasy sports platform. Texas law allows fantasy sports betting, so users can legally participate in both Best Ball and Pick’em contests on Underdog Fantasy. Like DraftKings, Underdog does not offer traditional sports betting in Texas, which remains illegal in the state.

Eligibility Requirements

The eligibility requirements for Pick6 and Underdog are the same in Texas. Both require you to be 18 or older and be physically located in the state to play. You’ll also need to create an account and provide personal information such as name, address, and age for identity verification.

Sign-Up Process for DraftKings Pick6 and Underdog Fantasy

The sign-up processes for Pick6 and Underdog are very similar. Both platforms require creating an account with personal details, agreeing to terms, and verifying age. Additionally, you’ll need to make a deposit if you plan to enter paid contests on either platform.

DraftKings Pick6DK PIck6 Sign-up

  1. Visit the Website or App: Go to the DraftKings website or download the DraftKings app from your device’s app store.
  2. Create an Account: Click on “Sign Up” to create an account. You’ll need to provide personal details, such as:
    • Full Name
    • Email Address
    • Date of Birth (to verify you’re at least 18 or 21, depending on your state)
    • Physical Address (for location verification)
    • Last Four Digits of Your Social Security Number (for identity verification)
  3. Agree to Terms: Review and accept DraftKings’ terms and conditions.
  4. Deposit Funds: To participate in paid contests, make an initial deposit using methods like credit/debit cards, PayPal, or bank transfer.
  5. Start Playing: After signing up and verifying your account, you can then explore the site, enter free contests and paid Pick6 contests, and withdraw funds.

Underdog FantasyUnderdog App Screenshot Free Pick

  1. Visit the Website or App: Go to the Underdog Fantasy website or download the Underdog Fantasy app.
  2. Create an Account: Tap “Sign Up” to create an account. You’ll need to provide personal details, including:
    • Full Name
    • Email Address
    • Date of Birth (to verify you meet the age requirement, typically 18 or 21)
    • Username and Password (for logging into your account)
  3. Agree to Terms: Accept Underdog Fantasy’s terms and conditions and privacy policy.
  4. Deposit Funds: To participate in paid contests, you’ll need to make a deposit using options like credit/debit cards or PayPal.
  5. Start Playing: Once your account is set up, you can join Best Ball leagues or Pick’em contests based on your state’s eligibility.

Can you win money at DraftKings Pick6 and Underdog?

You can win money at both DraftKings Pick6 and Underdog Fantasy. Both platforms offer the chance to win cash through paid contests.

DraftKings Pick6

Paid Contests: In paid Pick6 contests, you can win cash prizes based on your performance in the fantasy sports matchups you select. The prizes are awarded to the top scorers in each contest.

Free Contests: In free contests, you typically win site credits or free entries into future contests, rather than cash.

Underdog Fantasy

Paid Contests: In paid contests like Best Ball and Pick’em, you can win cash prizes based on your performance and how well you predict player stats or perform in leagues.

Free Contests: Similar to DraftKings, Underdog offers free-to-play contests, but the rewards are typically site credits or free entries into paid contests.

Underdog App Screenshot Streaks

DraftKings Pick6 Win Screenshot

Deposit and Payout Methods at DraftKings Pick6 vs. Underdog Fantasy

Underdog Fantasy has fewer payout options compared to DraftKings, although both platforms offer credit/debit card, PayPal, and bank transfer options for deposits and withdrawals. DraftKings Pick6 has additional methods like DraftKings Play+ Prepaid Card and physical checks for payouts, which I found to be an added convenience.

DraftKings Pick6 payment methods

Deposit Methods

  • Credit/Debit Cards: Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express.
  • PayPal: A common method for funding your account.
  • Bank Transfers: Direct transfers from your bank account.
  • DraftKings Play+ Prepaid Card: A prepaid card for easy deposits and withdrawals.
  • Apple Pay: For users who prefer using Apple Pay to make deposits.

Payout Methods:

  • PayPal: Fast and secure withdrawal method.
  • Bank Transfers: You can request a direct bank transfer to withdraw your funds.
  • DraftKings Play+ Prepaid Card: Withdrawals can be processed onto the Play+ card for use at other locations or withdrawal to your bank.
  • Checks: You can request a physical check if preferred, but it can take longer.

Underdog Fantasy payment methods

Deposit Methods:

  • Credit/Debit Cards: Visa and MasterCard.
  • PayPal: A fast and convenient method for depositing funds into your account.
  • Apple Pay: Available for users who prefer to use Apple Pay for deposits.
  • ACH Bank Transfers: Direct transfer from your bank account for deposits.
  • Underdog Fantasy Gift Cards: Some users can deposit through gift cards.

Payout Methods:

  • PayPal: Quick and secure method for withdrawing your winnings.
  • ACH Bank Transfers: Withdraw funds directly to your bank account.
  • Credit/Debit Cards: Some users can withdraw funds back to their credit/debit card if eligible, but this may depend on the specific bank or financial institution.

Free play options

Both Pick6 and Underdog offer free play options. DraftKings Pick6 focuses on non-cash prizes (like site credits or free contest entries) in most free contests. On the other hand, Underdog Fantasy offers non-cash rewards as well as cash prizes in some free contests. As a whole, however, I found that Underdog has limited free contests available compared to DraftKings Pick6.

DraftKings Pick6Underdog Fantasy
Free Play AvailabilityYes - Offers free contests in addition to paid onesYes - Offers free contests, often for new users or promotions
What You Win in Free PlaySite credits, free entries into paid contests, or non-cash prizesCash prizes, site credits, or free entries into paid contests
LimitationsNo cash prizes in most free contests; prizes are often non-cash or promotionalLimited availability for free contests; cash prize eligibility might depend on specific contests or promotions

Final verdict: DraftKings Pick6 vs Underdog Fantasy

Both DraftKings Pick6 and Underdog Fantasy cater to fantasy sports enthusiasts, and I found much to enjoy about each platform. Pick6 focuses on player matchups and predictions, while Underdog Fantasy focuses on player props and drafts. Both platforms offer a mix of free and paid contests, with cash prizes awarded to top performers.

If you’re looking for a real-money daily fantasy platform that is user-friendly and fully functional, DraftKings Pick6 is the way to go. And if you’re in search of a platform that offers a fresh daily fantasy perspective in the way of unique contest options, take Underdog Fantasy for a test drive.

DraftKings Pick6Underdog Fantasy
Type of PlatformFantasy Sports (focus on player matchups and predictions)Fantasy Sports (focus on player props and drafts)
GameplayPredict the outcome of 6 player matchups across various sportsPick over/under predictions on player props or best ball drafts
Betting StyleFantasy Sports format, selecting matchups and forecasting player performanceFantasy Sports format, selecting player props or entering drafts
Entry FeeFree or Paid contests (depending on the contest)Free or Paid contests (depending on the contest)
Available StatesAvailable in most states where fantasy sports are legalAvailable in most states where fantasy sports are legal
Social AspectOffers community features, such as leaderboards and sharing contestsLimited social features, but best ball drafts can involve friends or groups
PayoutCash prizes in paid contests based on performanceCash prizes in paid contests or draft winnings, based on player props or drafts
Target AudienceFantasy sports fans interested in player performance predictionsFantasy sports fans interested in player prop picks or best ball drafts

Other options similar to DraftKings Pick 6 & Underdog

If you’re looking for other DFS options similar to Pick6 and Underdog, you can check out these three reviews for other pick’em-style sites that we also recommend: